How many backups do I really need (ongoing CCC issues)

Agreed. My backup drives (for both TM and CCC) are 4TB, which is about 4x the data stored on my Mac’s 2TB SSD.

When it comes time to replace these drives, budget notwithstanding, I’ll probably upgrade them to 6 TB drives, just to give myself more headroom.

1 Like

Did you reach a verdict on this test with the old disk?

I actually like WD disks, but not their enclosures. The easystore and Elements devices are kinda slow. I went with Bombich’s recommendation of using a WD Black disk in an Oyen Novus enclosure for my larger data archive and I’ve been pretty happy with it. For my startup disk backup, I use a Samsung SSD. Also very happy with that.

1 Like

I think the important detail to keep in mind when deciding whether something is or is not a backup is if you can recover data from it in all common disaster scenarios. The problem with iCloud is that in the case of file corruption or accidental deletion, the cloud version suffers from the same problem, and it does so almost instantly.

With a duplicate, you are correct that deleting a file and then running another duplicate will  prevent you from recovering that file, but the backup is complete until another run happens. This is why a RAID system is not really a backup system—all changes are reflected immediately.

That’s also why versioned backups, such as Time Machine and Backblaze do by default, and CCC can do optionally, are an important part of a backup strategy.

Now, just because cloud storage services and RAIDs aren’t true backups doesn’t mean they aren’t extremely useful for protecting your data and recovering from certain kinds of catastrophes.

2 Likes

Yes, but you have to do your homework. WD makes many different models, some of which are good, some are acceptable and some are not acceptable (at least to me). Some key features to consider:

  • Rated for 24x7 operation. Many are only rated for 8x5 operation (business hours) or don’t have a rating. You want 24x7 for drives that are rarely powered off.
  • 7200 RPM. Slower drives will be noticeably slower.
  • SMR vs. CMR. Avoid SMR - it can cause severe performance degradation when writing a lot of data.

The Black series are targeted at the gamer community. High performance, but not rated for 24x7 operation. So great for archives and backup drives that aren’t always powered, but bad (IMO) for something that’s powered all the time (on-line storage, Time Machine or other scheduled backup system).

My recommendations for WD is their Red Pro and Gold series. These are relatively high performance, CMR, 7200 RPM and rated for 24x7 operation.

1 Like

I don’t particularly trust Time Machine, but I can definitely say CCC is awesome if your Mac harddisk dies, or even if your Mac just generally dies. Having an identical clone that you can get straight back up and working is definitely a good thing, much better than having to wait for a long tedious restore before getting going (which you’ll likely need to do to transfer back to the internal disk, but you can do it on your own time).

BackBlaze is a great addition for those cases where you need to recover things on a more granular level.

My 4 TB HDD backup drive failed two years ago after 11 years of service. The drive mechanism was a HGST Deskstar 7K4000 SATA 6Gb/s, 7200 RPM.

I replaced it with a Toshiba X300 (512 MB cache HDWR740XZSTA $124.99). I think it is pretty zippy.

I repeat what I’ve said before: when it comes to HDD drives, stay away from shingled storage if at all possible.

2 Likes

Every couple years I question my backup system & often make a change or 2 suggested by TidBits members.
I have only 1 computer, an iMac. I also have an iPad & and iPad mini; they’re helpful & useful but know they can’t fully back up an iMac. All iMac info is strictly for personal use, I’m retired. But some of the personal stuff can be very crucial what w/financial planning, tax data records, health info, home info, and the like. I use 3 forms of backup for my iMac:

  1. Samsung Portable SSD T7 USB 3.2 2TB for Time Machine Backups solid state hard drive
  2. iCloud 50gm storage/back up
  3. Back Blaze auto back up to cloud

Do I have an adequate level of backup for the iMac? Anything I should add, delete, substitute? I used have a flash drive for manual backup for some of the critical files as a 4th backup method. But I got the impression from TidBits members that the flash drive back up was no longer necessary so I stopped it a couple years ago.

The standard backup response has always been the 3-2-1 setup; three backups, two different media, and one offsite.

I’m retired but still value my data. I have my MBP with Desktop & Documents on the cloud - I find this extremely handy if I want to log in from another machine, and for migration to new machines it’s basically seamless. My substantial photo library is kept on an M.2 RAID1 enclosure, with the Lightroom catalog stored locally on my machine.

I have TimeMachine running on a fast, mirrored RAID using SSDs. I have two different CCC drives, one which connects automatically, and one which I don’t use much these days. The photo drive is backed up to a RAID5 enclosure, with another copy onto a Synology NAS in a seperate building.

For the past several months I’ve been using Arq for offsite - it seems good and requires zero thought to backup everything on my machine as well as the photo disks. There’s a cost due to the amount of data, but it’s not much (and a cost I’m happy to wear.)

For anyone wondering why I have such a large and diverse array of storage, the company I was working for closed down shortly after I retired. They asked me if I wanted anything so I helped myself to a couple of OWC Thunderbays (RAID 5), and a couple of Synology Nas’s (also RAID 5). There were various smaller mirrored enclosures which I also grabbed, and simply replaced the drives with new SSDs. One day I’ll simplify things a bit but for now I feel I’m well covered.

Forgot to add: I also use Dropbox for frequently used important files. Using Dropbox makes it easier to view those documents when using an iPad or iPhone. I rarely make changes to Dropbox files when using an iPad or iPhone but it’s helpful to be able to access them. For example, info I might need a list of meds @ the doctor’s office or review test results.

While I don’t think of Dropbox as a backup, I find it great for sharing files and folders. And I have a lot of stuff in there too. For things like a list of meds, I put them in a Medical folder inside Notes.

1 Like

This is a tangent to the original post, but I use (a nearly infinitesimal fraction of) my iCloud storage, also 50 Gbyte, for exactly the same thing. As a geezer, now fully in the grip of the medical-industrial complex, the list of my current meds is probably the most frequently accessed file in my iCloud storage. Indeed, the convenience of accessing files in iCloud, as well as not needing to share files (e.g. paper drafts) with my colleagues for editing once I retired, led me to drop (sorry) Dropbox after years of use.

I keep Dropbox as it has the ability to store selected files directly on the device, w/o internet or cell service. My iPad has wifi but not cell service so I can’t always connect to iCloud or if I can, I need to access a wifi network w/a password. It’s easier to keep some documents directly on the device, no internet necessary.
Occasionally, I’m in a location w/poor cell service, which makes accessing iCloud difficult, even w/my iPhone. I’d like to get rid of Dropbox but it seems to be the only way to have access to specific files w/o internet or cell service.
I’m also a geezer so while I appreciate I no longer have to carry hard copies of everything, I still don’t like being 100% dependent on internet access.

If any of your data is irreplaceable, sensitive, or highly valuable in some way, I would add a physical, non-Time Machine backup.

I maintain backups using Time Machine and Carbon Copy Cloner. The Time Machine drive is always connected. The CCC drive is disconnected most of the time. I do a CCC backup about once a week or before installing an OS update.

I do this for redundancy and to increase the chances of having a clean version of my entire setup in the event of a catastrophic failure or a security breach. I’m also not dependent on an Internet connection for restores or recoveries.

3 Likes

Just an update: Time Machine continues to run hourly since restarting my MBP - currently running MacOS 27.0.1. So that problem was fixed with a simple restart.

At the suggestion of Mike from Bombich I decided to start CCC again to see if maybe it was ok now. Unfortunately CCC continues to lag to the point where it seems it will never finish (see latest screenshot).

I’ve reported back to Bombich and will see what their next suggestion is.

And I also do like Dropbox, which people have been talking about. I find it convenient for sharing files with other people. And I use 2 TB of iCloud, which is great for syncing. And Backblaze, which appears to be running and up-to-date, though I’ve never tried to recover anything from it.

I admit it would be nice to also have CCC running well like it used to.

1 Like

Are you aware that you can also use iCloud for sharing files and/or folders? It’s fairly similar to how Dropbox works.

I can just copy the iCloud particular folder link and share it with anybody and they can see all the contents of the folder?

Yes, that is correct.
See the Apple Support page at this link for more information.

Doubt I’ll use iCloud to share a file (rarely have need to share a file) but I’m curious: if you share an iCloud file w/someone, do they need to have their own iCloud account to open/see the file? Or is a shared link enough for someone to open/see the file?

See the Apple support link above to answer your question in more detail, but the short answer is “no iCloud account is required” (apart from the person initiating the share).

I did read it before I asked, must have missed that portion on the page; a very wordy page. :face_with_hand_over_mouth:Thank you for your reply.