What's your best method to run Civilization IV today?

I’ve finally decided to give up on modern Civ. I just want to play Civ IV. I used to play on older Mac through Steam, but have to admit, I wasn’t a huge fan of that solution. Steam needs updates, those force OS updates, and that tends to clash with just running an old game in perpetuity.

So, assuming you don’t want to play against others or otherwise over the internet, this device could run air-gapped and thus forever on a completely outdated macOS.

I could right now buy a 2014 Retina 15" 2.5 GHz quad i7 / 16 / 256 in excellent condition for $319. Using Mr. Macintouch I can get my hands on High Sierra to create a bootable installer and use that to install a 32-bit macOS that should run just fine on that old MBP. I assume I can find a Civ IV installer disk on the used market and get that installed via USB3 DVD drive.

Now, this solution does have the disadvantage that it requires dedicated hardware rather than running on a modern Mac (via emulation). But I like that it offers the potential to set it up once and then just forget about it and play forever, without worrying about updates, cloud, expiring services, forced upgrades, etc.

What holes can you blow into this? Anything better than suits that bill?

I’d say it depends on how much $$$ and time you can spend. If you are OK with just replacing the machine if it breaks down or you don’t mind dealing with old-computer-problems such as power supply, capacitor, and solder breakdowns, buying a dedicated Mac to run an old game could be fun.

I don’t play Civilization so I don’t know which platforms it appears on but an easy way to play a lot of old games, if they are available, is on a console. In fact, one reason I got into game consoles is because I got tired of macOS updates making games unplayable and Apple hardware changes making game controllers (anybody want to buy my ADB steering wheel? ha ha) unusable.


ETA: I’m primarily a PlayStation user, so I’m not that familiar with Steam. But doesn’t Steam sell a handheld and a console?

Would it work to run the Windows version? Do you have the ARM version of Windows 11, to run in VMware Fusion or Parallels?

1 Like

You asked a very similar question in 2022?

I think the conclusion them was to use Steam. But if that is no longer acceptable, I still think it’s worth checking to see if your can run an old version of macOS in a VM or emulator. Performance won’t be great, but may be good enough for an old game like Civ IV.

1 Like

Yeah, I just didn’t find that route very enjoyable. Hence the new thread. But, yeah, the topic is very similar.

If I prefer to abandon the Steam path, is there an argument to be made for the VM/emulator route apart from that allowing to run it on modern hardware? I guess I’m asking about the tradeoff between having to deal with old hardware vs. having to deal with virtualization/emulation. As somebody who’s been with Mac since the very first one in 84 and still equipped with a museum’s worth of older Macs, I am obviously biased. Still, curious to hear others’ thoughts.

As someone who keeps old hardware for game playing (an Apple IIGS, a 486 PC and a PowerPC Mac), I don’t have a problem with doing that.

But it’s another computer to maintain/manage, parts are hard/impossible to get, and it may take a lot of your time when something fails.

And how often will you want to boot up that computer just to play an old game? My old gaming computers are rarely turned on, because it just doesn’t occur to me when I’m looking for something to do. An app on your main computer, even running in an emulator, is more likely to get used.

Hell, I’ve been looking for years for a practical way to play Civ II — Sid Meier lost me at version III. Good luck!

Well good thing we had this little discussion here. It reminded me that I had an old 2010 15" MBP lying around here somewhere. Sure enough, it’s still doing fine, it has a decent enough battery, it has the OG MagSafe charger that still works (albeit with a somewhat questionable cable), and it has High Sierra. So I guess now I just need to get my hands on the universal binary DVD. Those go for 8 bucks used on Amazon right now so that’s in the bag too. I just hope that DVD doesn’t need to be inserted all the time to play. It’s been such a long time since I last played that version I have forgotten entirely how that all worked.

I remember there being passive adapters to use OG MagSafe chargers with MagSafe 2 MacBooks. But what about the other way around? Any dongle to use a newer MagSafe2 charger with an OG MagSafe Mac? I can’t find anything trustworthy. I found a couple for USB-C PD to MagSafe 1, but reviews aren’t ecstatic.

You don’t need to use something with a screen. We have a 2012 Mac Mini (Fusion Drive) which we keep always on. No need for a permanently connected monitor so it doesn’t take up desk space - set up with auto login. It has all the old games that my wife likes to play. She connects from her modern iMac using Jump and runs them as if on her iMac. Can use inbuilt screen sharing but some games become unusably jerky - Jump avoids those issues.

While not about Civ IV, I recently started thinking about a new virtualization project.

I have a collection of VMware and Parallels VMs running Mac OS versions 10.6 (Snow Leopard Server) through 12.x (Monterey) along with various versions of Windows as guests on an i7 mid-2012 13" MacBook Pro running Catalina as the host OS.

Given the age of the machine and some recent suspicious hardware behavior, I’ve been contemplating moving the VMs to a somewhat more recent Linux desktop I have.

I realize that this would not be an officially supported solution, but since Intel Macs are dead ends with very limited storage options, and any compatible Intel box made in the last few years would be significantly faster than my old MBP, I think it may be a reasonable solution. It seems that people are reliably running Mac VMs on non-Apple hosts these days without too much patching or configuration tweaks to enable them. The other nice thing is that I can move the 4 TB SSD I have in the MBP to a Linux desktop without too much work, aside from reformatting the drive and transferring files.

Of course, as I get older, I also find myself wondering whether I should just scrap the old VMs entirely. :expressionless_face:

Ha ha ha!

Dave

1 Like

Virtual Intel Mac on Apple silicon will run the old Mac version

For Porting Kit or CrossOver I’d recommend the GOG version rather than Steam (which I agree is not a great experience).

5 Likes