The stuff introduced with Big Sur and Monterey was just painful, and yet this is even worse. Does Apple employ anyone anymore who is good at design? Anyone who has eyes?
I only see my Desktop wallpaper at startup. The rest of the time it is covered up by application windows, Finder icons, and documents. So whatever Apple chooses doesn’t delight me or anger me much.
Personally, I regard “good” design as subjective. An iPhone that is as thin as a piece of paper and looks like a clear slab of glass sounds extremely attractive to some, for example. But I would rather have some physical ports and enough heft to be able to avoid dropping my phone a lot.
I use my desktop to have a slide show going. Sometimes it’s covered by windows, sometimes not; never covered with files, though. I could probably manage with tiled lizards.
With a few exceptions, I’ve never used Apple’s wallpapers or desktop pics.
I have my own “collections” (most from saved pics I’ve seen here and there).
I remember when Windows 11 came out and comparing its included themes with Big Sur. At the time, I thought of the famous Steve Jobs quote about Microsoft’s lack of taste and thought that somehow, the roles had reversed. Sure, there are a lot of things to criticize about Windows 11, but strip away the various nags, and the underlying aesthetics are pretty good.
Yeah, I just helped a neighbor get a donated computer running Windows 11 and overall it is not bad. The task bar is pretty awful, but that’s not an aesthetic issue.
I took some portraits of my wife to be in 1977, and cropped versions make a slideshow for my desktop picture (why do we have to use the Windows term ‘wallpaper’?) Makes her smile when she sees them still, although this year it will be fifty years since we met.