Originally published at: Is the Vision Pro Too Immersive? - TidBITS
Nick Bilton worries about a day when our desire for the dopamine hit of Vision Pro-augmented makes all other devices feel flat and dull.
Oh FFS. Exactly how far back should time be rolled? Mid 20th? Late 19th? Late 17th (Shakespeare!)? Earlier? Socrates had some concerns about things.
Iāve seen sweaty trembling articles about the New Thing Destroying Our Lives literally every year since I was old enough to read (mid-70s). Wait until I tell you how the VCR is going to obliterate social cohesion. My parents parents freaked out about the telephone. Their parents trembled at the radio.
Everybody take a deep, long breath.
4 Likes
3D TV did not workout as I recall. For this to work there has to be more practical applications and a lower price point for people to engage with it.
1 Like
Good point. And 3D TV makes an interesting parallel. Its Archilles heel is that it is hard on the human eye, causing eyestrain that becomes a headache or nausea, and that gets worse over time. From my research, AR/VR headsets also cause eyestrain that gets progressively worse the longer you wear them. If that holds for Apple Vision, eyestrain may limit how long people will wear it.
I wonder how much the Apple Vision experience varies with your eyesight?
What ridiculous hyperbole. The fact the articleās author is a āslaveā to their smartphone says more about them than their phone. I greatly appreciate the convenience and utility of my iPhone, but I also have no problem living my life how I want and only using it on my terms. It doesnāt provide me ādopamine hitsā.
2 Likes
My grandparents, parents and other relatives on both sides of the family would reminisce about how there were people were running and screaming in the streets of New York City during Orson Wellsā radio broadcast of āWar Of The Worldsā in 1938.
There have been a number of TV and film adaptations of āWar Of The Worlds,ā and there are popular video games, as well as apps in the App Store:
Iāll bet it will make a popular game on Vision Pro.
1 Like
Think again about this criticism. Itās more of a backhanded tribute than a real problem. Surely those of us old enough to roam the earth before computers can see forward to a day when sitting at a desk will be seen as the pure spinal torture it really is and roaming around, erect and using our bodies to gesture, as the only natural way to get work done. My lower back was nearly destroyed in the 90s sitting there staring for hours making tiny twitches with my mouse. This is a product category with a long way to go, true, but I think you have to be extremely hidebound and reactionary not to see the way itās going. We have seen this ourselves, before!
1 Like
While the hand-wringing is clearly clickbait, the immediate aftermath of sitting for a Vision Pro demo at the Apple Store mirrors my experience. Almost as stunning as the demo itself was the lingering feeling that other screens seemed small, flat, and not as interesting.
2 Likes
But this is nothing new. When I got my 65" HDR TV, movies watched on my other TVs (about 40" and smaller) started seeming small and boring. When I got a 24" LCD screen on my computer, the 17" CRT it replaced ended up feeling small and blurry.
When I first got a DVD player, my old VHS movies (which I used to have no problem with) suddenly felt painful to watch.
Any time you experience something ābetterā, however you define that, the things that you used to consider good no longer feel that way because you want to keep using āthe good stuffā.
This isnāt a problem. Itās human nature.
3 Likes
Donāt mean to get off the topic, but here is an interesting article from USA Today.
Did āThe Simpsonsā predict Appleās Vision Pro?
Metaās entire business model is built around constant dopamine hits. They have a VR headset. Somehow they have not managed to make that into tech fentanyl. I think weāll be OK.
To an extent, but I donāt think itās particularly controversial to note that many people, especially kids, have problems moderating their tech usage and suffer negative consequences because of it. Thatās why Apple introduced ScreenTime.
One of Tristanās acquaintances growing up really screwed up his life because he was incapable of resisting the urge to play video games. His grades suffered, he didnāt get into the college he wanted, and he flamed out of the college he did get into. Obviously, there are lot of specifics built in there, but it was an actual addiction problem.
And while thatās anecdote, thereās plenty of research into the topic too, such as:
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8204720/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9368281/
So I donāt think itās unreasonable to ponder what the unintended consequences might be and have discussions about whether there are ways of mitigating them before they become problematic at the scale of a mainstream technology. Thereās plenty of room between āOMG, itās evil!ā and āAll new tech advances humanity.ā
4 Likes
Iām holding out for the next tech:
Device Free Fully Interactive Holographic Interface
DFFIHI
ā¦ or should that better read HI-DFFI
ā¦
IMHO
I completely agree, but for me someone loses credibility when they use the kind of hyperbole quoted above. I switch off because I have limited time and I donāt have any faith Iāll be reading a well thought out exploration and discussion. (For avoidance of doubt, Iām not referring to you, Adam, but to the Nick Bilton quote!)
2 Likes
My daughter and I had the Vision Pro demo appointments last evening. And, I only went along because she asked me to. I have been hesitant to even think about such an expense for āfunā!
Unfortunately, for my budget, I think that I have not had as much FUN with a toy since I was a kid. It was so simple to use and get used to. Yes, the headset is heavy and dorky looking. But when you are inside, it is like a sci-fi experience. Not real, but not not real, if you get my drift. And, when 3 baby rhinos approach you, you instinctively reach out to pet them. When the bear steps into the river on your right, you are in awe and just a teeny bit afraid. Everything is truly like being there without being there.
If that means flat screens are dull and no longer interesting, so be it. But I donāt think we need to worry about that just yet. As @silbey says: take a deep breath. It is not the end of the world as we know it. The immersive videos are unbelievable and thrilling. The 3-D Avatar was okay, but I get car sick in 3-D situations, so I had to back out of that demo. But there is so much more to the Vision Pro than 3-D movies.
It is really amazing technology that gives people with $$$ another way to spend it. I think I am going to save up and give myself a birthday present. Everyone deserves something special for their 80th birthday, right? Never too old to have a good time.
BTW, the optical inserts cost $149, pretty reasonable compared to the cost of the unit itself. Apple has a way to take your current eyeglasses and configure the inserts to approximate your prescription for the demo. That was flat out amazing to me as my vision was one of my main concerns and the reason I went to the demo: can people with imperfect eyesight still enjoy the experience? Yes, they can!
If you live near and Apple store doing demos, book a time and go have yourself a good time!
7 Likes
I think Nick had a good time. About all there was to it on reading the article.
Weāve all had the experience with new kit. Iām looking at my iPhone 11 Pro and have not checked out the 15 because my otherwise perfectly fine device will be diminished in comparison.
The experience is not just technolust, itās party biochemical, physical. In color grading photographs I have to be aware of it, editing contrast curves and color profiles. When flipping back to the original images they can appear duller and flatter than they did on first viewing. Waiting some time and coming back to the edited photographs, these can sometimes need to be dialled back. Our bodies respond in all sorts of ways to stimulus, tolerances and expectations play their part.
3 Likes
My husband and I are still doing fine with our 8+ iPhones. To date they do everything we need.