Has Apple Abandoned the iPod touch?

Shame. I use the Touch for garage/outdoor work music when I have phone on charger.

Anyway, anyone recommend/experience Tarkan or other SDcard adaptor to convert clickwheel iPods I found in a drawer? (one was free, as my late Doctor said it died and wanted me to get songs off for him, and never wanted it back. Needs battery and I thought, hmmm, put 128GB or larger SDXC card in, with new 2000ah battery… and where is that 30pin cable…LOL).

I’ve never personally attempted any of the following (and therefore I am definitely not recommending anything), but as I understand it:

  • If you have an iPod mini (unlikely, I know), the internal drive is a microdrive. I’m pretty sure you can replace it with any Compact Flash card (at least up to 128GB).

    You can also use the removed microdrive with a USB CF adapter (if it can provide enough current to power a microdrive) and access it from a computer. It should be formatted as either HFS+ or FAT, depending on whether your iPod was formatted for Windows or macOS.

  • A full-size iPod (including the Classic) uses a 1.8" hard drive. I know you can get adapters that allow flash-based storage to be used in lieu of a hard drive. I think the “Tarkan” adapters you’re referring to are the iFlash adapters. (I think “Tarkan” is the on-line user name for the person making the iFlash).

    iFlash makes a variety of adapters that allow you to use SD (1 or 2 cards), MicroSD (up to 4 cards), CompactFlash, mSATA, and M.2 SATA devices.

    I haven’t actually used one of these, but I have read the web site enough to know that you should be careful about the model you get. Not all are compatible with all iPods and you may require an adapter (especially if you have a 3rd or 4th gen iPod).

Once you replace your iPod’s storage, you should be able to format/restore it via iTunes (or the Finder on more recent versions of macOS).

One other thing to be aware of is that if you put in a very large storage device, you may not be able to use it all. According to the iFlash compatibility page:

  • 6th generation and older iPods use 28-bit logical-block addressing, so they are unable to access more than 128GB. So don’t bother trying to put more than that in such a unit. Only the 7th generation iPod (late 2009 160G Classic) can support larger storage devices.

  • There is also a database limit to the number of tracks an iPod can store, no matter how large the storage device may be. This limit is either about 20,000 or about 50,000 tracks, depending on your iPod model.

    At an average of 8MB per song (2MB per minute - 256Mbps compression - for 4 minute songs), 20,000 tracks is about 160GB. At this ratio, 50,000 tracks is about 400GB. Or conversely, at this compression, 128GB can hold a maximum of 16,000 songs.

    Be sure to keep this in mind when selecting the size of your SD card (assuming you have a 7th gen, which can accept more than 128G).

  • Both of these limits can be bypassed by replacing the Apple software with third-party music player software like Rockbox. I wouldn’t recommend doing this - it is an unsupported configuration and you won’t be able to manage its music with iTunes (nor will you be able to play DRM-protected tracks).

In other words, if you’re comfortable opening your iPod to do the actual work, I think it’s a good idea, but do your homework to make sure you get all the parts you need and that everything is compatible with your iPod.

3 Likes

The iPod Touch devices are ideal for retail POS and industrial usage such as bar-code scanners and technician tools, etc. That is the market where Apple sells most of these. I don’t know if they still use then at Apple Retail as portable POS devices but it’s possible. IBM has pivoted much of it’s work to Mobile workflow App development and consulting. A field technician could make use of an iPod Touch. They really just need Wi-Fi and the computer functionality of an iPhone without paying for an iPhone. They also don’t really need high end graphics, etc.

3 Likes

Josh, the touch is very much alive and well on Apple’s online store website:

I think the point is that while the iPod Touch is still available on the Apple Store, it had not been updated for nearly three years and been facing quite a bit of identity crisis, i.e. questions about its place in the Apple product lineup. Apple seems to be doing the minimum to keep iPod Touch going - the 2019 update gave the Touch an A10 processor, which was already 3 year old at the time. One can only access the iPod Touch page from the Apple homepage via a link at the bottom. (Also, the macOS auto-correct doesn’t even have iPod Touch in the vocabulary - it tries to correct “Touch” to “touch” - but helpfully corrects “macbook pro” to “MacBook Pro”.)

Look carefully at Apple’s store: Apple spells the product “iPod touch” with a lower-case ‘t’.

3 Likes

Wait, why I didn’t notice this all these years? Definitely worth adding to this thread - Thanks @ddmiller for pointing this out, I stand corrected!

1 Like

Alive, yes. Well? Not so much.

I only know this because Adam drilled it into my head.

One thing that some users might want is CarPlay ability for music only for example, which is not available on the iPod touch. I know some people just keep old iPods connected to their vehicles through USB for music as opposed to using flash drives or bluetooth.

Today, macworld.com has an article,

First item on their list: iPod touch.

Someone made the excellent point that the iPod touch is a great business device, especially for mobile checkout terminals. I’m not sure if the Apple Store still uses them, but they used to. Now that I think about it, that’s probably at least 80% of the use case.

The last time I was in an Apple Store, I’m pretty sure that the employees all had iPad terminals they carried, with integrated payment terminals. (I haven’t been in Apple stores much in the last two years, but I went in last summer for a Genius Bar appointment.)

Same here.

My local store in Dedham uses iPod touch sized devices with a card reader of some sort, certainly not iPad sized. Certainly for the last six years or so, I haven’t been in since January 2022.

My recollection is the same for the UK/French and other US stores I have visited, albeit not so recently.

f

I love iPod touch and deeply resent its neglect. I use it as a general-purpose networked bedroom media consumption device and it means I don’t have to carry my phone from room to room while I’m not using it. It’s the true heir to iOS, IMO, in the sense that the hardware draws out the software’s general-purpose nature in such a small package without the bulk of GPS or cellular radios. You don’t need lots of power to web-browse, email, message and phone call (via continuity), bank online, catch up on news, etc. And, yes, there’s that lovely headphone jack. Even the lack of Touch ID is something I now find I’m not all bothered about–you can set the lock timeout to an hour, use a four-digit PIN, and still have a sensibly convenient yet moderately secure device.

I do hope Apple update it! If not then I’ll have to look at iPhone SE again, although as of now it maxes out at half the storage (128 GB to iPod’s 256 GB). Perhaps if iPhone SE is updated first, I’ll just get that. Depends on how it goes down–not long to wait.

1 Like

I replaced my iPod (5th Gen, late 2006) with what I call my “iPod 3GS” years ago. It is my ancient iPhone 3GS repurposed. When I replace my current iPhone 10, my back-up iPhone 6 will probably become my “iPod 6”. I don’t really need the latest and greatest hardware/iOS for a music device.

Apple is blasting through internal and external redesigns of the entire Mac line. iPad and iPhone refreshes are also more important. In these busy times, I think it’s fine for the iPod Touch to get a bit long in the tooth. Hopefully, the design teams have already started a new refresh.

My favorite use of the iPod Touch was App Camp for Girls. I believe all the participants used (and kept) this device for their app development. It’s a nice cheap device for that purpose. I’m guessing employees at Apple are proud of the iPod Touch for the many roles the little device can play in the world.

2 Likes

Until the latest update, when I asked to open an app Siri would tell me that I would “need to unlock your iPod touch” first. Then it was “iPhone” and now it’s just “phone.” With the first change I thought it was just an oversight, but now I have to think it’s deliberate on Apple’s part, and doesn’t bode well for the touch’s future. Which is a shame — I use it for most small-scale tasks on the go, as I’m one of the four people remaining on the planet who doesn’t own a mobile phone :wink:

3 Likes

So Siri is now recognizing there are other phones than the iPhone? The word “phone” includes BOTH iPhones and Android phones.

Looks like the axe has fallen